AHRAR National Liberal Party
OpinionBy نبيل سمعانMachine translated from ArabicRead the Arabic original

No Value in Any Dialogue or Agreement That Contradicts Credibility and Political Realism

Media Secretary in the National Liberal Party

Journalist Nabil Samaan

It is enough to know the identity of the guests on any political program to automatically deduce the context of the imminent contentious dialogue, the sharpness of the expressions, and the entrenchment behind preconceived positions.

Our contemporary world is changing around us and developing through openness – who would have imagined that Ahmed al-Sharaa would today be a guest of Donald Trump at the White House! – while we in Lebanon mostly circle in a closed intellectual swamp. We swing in it between two terms, weapons and peace:

Weapons in their regional dimension have fallen 'technologically', as shown by the fact that we are far too powerless to 'shoo away' the drones from over our heads, while the Israeli defense doctrine has shifted from containment to preemption.

As for weapons in their internal dimension, they remain the more calamitous. Whoever sanctifies them – 'the Party of the Islamic Revolution in Lebanon, with the angels fighting at its side' – identifies with its ideological dream of dissolving the Lebanese entity. It is nothing new that its guardian has invested nearly a hundred billion in it for well over four decades, and still does!

In relations between individuals, parties, nations…, recognizing the right of the other is peace. And it is the right of the citizen who sincerely looks forward to a true national partnership, away from the glare of weapons, to ask: by what legitimacy does my brother in the homeland offer the greeting 'peace be upon you', when, with premeditation, wherever and whenever he wishes, he confiscates properties, digs beneath the very existence of an entity and rigs it with weapons caches in order to build a military structure that takes its orders tightly from Iran? He works unchecked to erase our collective memory and wipe out the history of a homeland and of the men who built it, he displaces people, he obliterates the expatriate's right to vote… and he waits for the coming opportunity to pounce on everything.

God Almighty has no weapons and no parties that take His name, and I, the Lebanese Christian citizen, openly refuse to be a soldier in the guardianship of the Pope of the Vatican!

The psychology of hostility and the prevailing absurdity remain the dilemma. It goes beyond the 'ideology of blood protects weapons' to express a collective identity immunized against the right to differ in opinion, with which there is neither room nor use for give-and-take in politics, because it stands diametrically opposed to the culture of life, the refinement of pluralism, and the specificity of Lebanon, the Homeland-Message.

And if we grant, out of a desire for positivity, that there are sincere, believing opinions and intentions that extol coexistence and the right to differ – and mine is among them – and that they converge on the view that a solution is possible and begins with rationality and frankness, with an end to betting on time and to the disdain for the minds of decent people – provided that intentions are sincere in searching together for the Lebanon we want – is achieving it possible?

After the discouraging experiences since 1982, through the Gaza support war, and the unilateralism of our brothers in the homeland with their imported decisions that boasted of, incited and invited occupation, up to the message addressed yesterday by the 'Party of Weapons' to the three presidents and to the 'proud people', in order, in its words, 'to avoid slipping into negotiating traps with the enemy', it becomes clear to near and far, beyond any doubt, that the insistence on clinging to a masked resistance that accumulates killing, destruction and defeats, with all the arrogance, boasting and feigned cleverness it entails in slogans of recovery, denial and obstinacy, not to mention the confiscation of the state's diplomatic decision, the wading into fallacies and twisted partial interpretations, the deliberate misleading about the content of international agreements – among them UN Resolution 1701, which is based on Resolution 1559 –, up to the selectivity in viewing the provisions of the cessation of hostilities agreement signed in November 2024, and the selective invoking of talk about internal unity, in keeping with the rejectionist (Mumana'a) narrative aimed at diverting attention and obscuring the facts…, all of this and much more gives it no credibility. Rather, it falls within the framework of mutual justifications with Israel: it is no secret that the latter, by occupying some border points, gives the 'Divine Party' the justification to keep its weapons, while deep down the Party does not care whether the occupation remains!

As long as this cycle keeps turning in the closed swamp, and with it the language of feigned cleverness, stalling and ambiguity 'between before and after the Litani… and the like…', Lebanon, state and homeland, will not find its sought-after goal of stability and progress, so long as weapons are used as a tool of external domination over its free decision under an internal mask. Nor will the homeland of the Cedar regain its natural position on the political map and among the civilized nations, unless its rulers officially dare to follow a policy of neutrality, firmness, clarity and openness, to affirm the option of diplomatic negotiation under an international umbrella about what Israel wants other than the weapons of the Divine Party, as a tool for ending the conflict and securing our rights rather than conceding them, and to cut off the road so that the latter's statement does not become, indirectly, closer to a message directed from Iran to the United States via the Lebanese arena.

Share

More like this