Is the Division of Lebanese Society a Reality or a Mirage?
By Attorney Joseph Qozayha Karam
Member of the Political Council
The Lebanese crisis raises a question about the nature of Lebanese society and its division into three groups.
The first group wants peace and wants direct negotiations. The second wants war and does not want direct negotiations. The last wants neither peace nor war, and does not know what kind of negotiations it wants.
As for the first group, there are fundamental obstacles preventing it from reaching the desired peace, among them the refusal of others to agree to it. Consequently, its going to direct negotiations will not affect the course of the war in any way, because of the intransigence of the second group, and it will not reach the peace it seeks.
The group that does not want peace and wants war cannot win. It cannot liberate the land or impose its conditions, whether regarding the outcome of this war or the form of the negotiations, since this depends on its supposed adversary, who does not accept to negotiate with it because, according to his statements, it is a terrorist organization that he wants to wipe from existence.
The dilemma lies here: if the first group negotiates, the second group refuses to abide by the outcome, claiming that it alone has the right to decide on war, on negotiations and on their form, that everyone must follow it, and that whoever departs from its positions is out of step with the times.
As for the third group, which wants neither war nor the attainment of peace and has taken no position on negotiations, it sits by the roadside waiting for the train that will come, so as to reserve a seat inside it.
A society divided in this way makes reaching peace impossible. Negotiations will inevitably be interrupted and fruitless, while the war machine continues, leading to the loss of land and to more killing.
Most importantly, those who do not want this war are made to bear its consequences, without being a party to it and without having any say in whether it continues or stops.
This situation will create a state of hostility and enmity among the components of society, bringing with it the need for self-defense. Woes and calamities will then multiply, and the clock will be turned back to a time that everyone seems to agree must not be revisited.
So that the same tragedy is not repeated, each group must have the right to exercise its freedom, organize its relations and live within the frameworks it deems suitable.
Let each choose what it wants, and let the members of this society agree, by consensus among its sons, to establish two federations, and indeed more than that, two confederations.
Whoever wants peace, let him make peace. Whoever wants war, let him continue fighting. And whoever wants nothing will in the end choose where and how to carry on his future.
And peace.