AHRAR National Liberal Party
OpinionBy فؤاد الأسمرMachine translated from ArabicRead the Arabic original

Sheikh Sami: The “Story” in a Non-Viable System

By Lawyer Fouad Al-Asmar

Secretary for Planning and Guidance of the National Liberal Party

An old wisdom says: “If you discover that you are riding a dead horse, the best strategy is to dismount.”

No two people disagree that Sheikh Sami Gemayel's speech during the confidence session for Prime Minister Nawaf Salam's government was impressive in its depth and patriotism. It shed light on the “story” of each civilizational group in Lebanon and called for agreement on a single national story that respects all the small stories.

However, his speech overlooked the core of the crisis, which is the centralized system that did not respect the pluralistic fabric of society and also established the rule of dividing quotas and the spoils of the state among the leaders of the sects.

With this system, belonging to Lebanon as a homeland vanished and was replaced by belonging to the sect-leader, making the “Lebanese story” non-viable.

The centralized system is the dead horse that the Lebanese ride behind leaders who, when they agree, plunder the harvests, and when they disagree, destroy the country and lead its “stories” into bloody wars.

Hundreds of previous dialogue sessions failed, not only because of illegitimate weapons and foreign agendas, but, more dangerously, because of the many bleeding wounds of the past.

Successful and constructive dialogue must start from rejecting mutual deceit and selfish interests, and from a serious, inclusive reconciliation that includes acknowledging the persistent mistakes and repenting of them, leading to learning from the experiences of other countries.

States with multiple cultures and a history of conflict have ended up with one of two outcomes: either partition, or adopting a federal system that protects the unity of the state, guarantees coexistence and positive interaction among its stories, and achieves the desired national story. This is what President Camille Nimr Chamoun called for fifty years ago.

Out of our deep respect for your person and your thought, Sheikh Sami, why the vagueness in presenting the solution when you know the answer and have struggled for years for it?

Share

More like this