Dictatorship, Secession, or the Federal System
Dictatorship, Secession, or the Federal System, by lawyer Fouad El Asmar, Secretary for Planning and Guidance in the National Liberal Party
The Sykes-Picot Agreement, concluded in 1916, divided the Ottoman Sultanate's possessions in the Arab Mashreq into French and British zones of influence. In fact, this agreement did not respect the plurality of cultural identities among the peoples of the region, and merged them into unitary, centralized states.
After these states gained independence, their components' lack of homogeneity led to coups and bloody clashes. These subsided only when military dictatorships came to power, particularly in Syria and Iraq, where they suppressed their peoples and ruled them with fire and gunpowder, and even with chemical weapons.
Today, with the fall of these dictatorships, sectarian, confessional and racial loyalties and instincts have stirred again, and scenes of daily massacres and bloody clashes between the components of these peoples have once more come to dominate the ground. In fact, many states with multiple identities have suffered wars and clashes between their components. Some of them opted for secession, so that the number of states in the world doubled from 102 in 1950 to 230 in 2000, while others decided to organize coexistence among their components. As a result, 40% of the world's population today lives in federal states.
We are now living through the same experience, and we face a choice of three: either a return to dictatorships on the basis of "injustice toward the subjects is justice in equal treatment," or partition of the region according to the identities of its peoples, or adoption of the federal system, which preserved the unity of the countries that adopted it, succeeded in achieving positive civilizational interaction among their cultural components, and established peace and prosperity throughout their lands.
So when will we let reason prevail, put an end to the language of accusations of treason and demagoguery, and learn from the experiences of developed and successful countries that have provided security, peace and prosperity for their peoples?