AHRAR National Liberal Party

Chamoun at the "Last Chance" Conference: Federalism to Prevent Partition

On the tenth anniversary of the founding of the Permanent Conference for Federalism, a preparatory conference was held under the title "The Last Chance..", attended by political and media figures. The discussion focused on the federalism proposal versus the secession proposal.

The Secretary-General began by welcoming the attendees. The late Camille Alfred Chamoun, one of the founders of the Permanent Conference for Federalism, was honored with a commemorative shield presented to his family in the presence of his wife Carol, his son Mark and his daughter Céline. Céline delivered the family's speech, recalling the late man's merits and thanking the conference for its initiative. The Secretary-General of the conference, Dr. Alfred Riachi, then opened the conference:

Alfred Riachi:

Riachi began by welcoming the attendees and opened his welcome speech as follows:

Ten bitter years. Many said, "You haven't gotten tired?" And the answer is surely no.

Ten years, and many said, "A few months and they'll get fed up." And the answer was: we haven't gotten fed up, and we won't..

Bitter years with many events: from the election of a "strong" president, and we saw the result: failed governments, "take this one," and parliaments, "take that one, take your hand and follow me".. and the problem remained..

The Palestinian, the Syrian and the Israeli all faded away, but the problem remained.

Since the day I was born, we have been living in this country of wars, to the point that it entered the Guinness Book of Records for wars as well as political assassinations. Its hallmark has become hatred, spite and resentment toward the other.. a country of perpetual violence. But is there no solution? Yes, and a thousand times yes: it is federalism. And if not everyone wants it, then surely there is also a solution, which is quite simply "secession".

Tomorrow a few agents may come to us under the label of "patriots" (wataniji).. and say, "You are agents." We will answer and say: be quiet.

Yes, we are agents. Agents of peace.

Yes, we are agents of freedom.

Yes, we are agents of humanity.

Yes, we are agents of justice and equality..

This is the "last chance" so that we do not go on killing one another; it is the last chance so that we do not seek foreign help against one another; it is the last chance to keep Lebanon's 10452 km².

But with all this, we said: let us stay together, and return to build a homeland of peace, a homeland of love and a homeland of prosperity. It truly is..

"The Last Chance".

Camille Chamoun:

President of the Nationalists Party, MP Camille Chamoun, delivered a speech in which he said that, since we are going through a delicate phase, and after a bitter period marked by tyranny, we have been left with only one choice for the continuation of this entity. How? By adopting the federal system, in order to preserve Lebanon.

Chamoun attacked what those with sincere intentions used to be labeled with: rhetoric of hatred and accusations of treason, which later showed who the traitor and who the agent really is..

He added that, since most politicians have a discourse of double standards that lacks clarity and vision, the result was the point that things have reached today.

"In the early days of the Lebanese war, my grandfather, the late President Camille Nimr Chamoun, proposed federalism as an option that would keep us from reaching partition. So we reiterate what my grandfather said: federalism, and then federalism, to prevent partition."

Ibrahim Mourad:

The President of the World Syriac Union Party, Mr. Ibrahim Mourad, said in his speech that "we should not rush now to fill the vacancy in the presidency of the Republic, but rather wait until we are done with the terror militia, so as to form a sovereign, independence-minded government. Only then can we elect a sovereign, independence-minded president who resembles our struggle and the path of our martyrs."

He said: "After that, I, the federalist, who have spared no effort with my comrades in defending the demand for establishing a federal system in Lebanon, and who have long been called 'the federalists'.. perhaps we have to wait two or three months. We have to endure, because we want a homeland, we want a state in whose shelter our children live with dignity and do not suffer as we have suffered. So we finish with terrorism and with every component that relies on outside powers against us, after we have finished with those who used to raise their finger 'politely' at us. The blood of our martyrs has not gone and will not go in vain."

He continued: "After finishing with all that, we must sit together and think, so that what has happened every 15 years does not repeat itself. We then work so that each component has its own entity, and we apply confederation later so that we may live in safety and peace, because even the application of federalism is no longer enough if we want to prevent the scenario of any sect, whose religious loyalty and affiliation lie abroad, overpowering the other sects and components."

Mourad concluded: "Let every Lebanese component have its own state, so that we may love one another, meet, and compete in a civilized manner, by adopting confederation, for it is the solution." He thanked all the "federalist comrades for their long struggle and for every effort they made, placing themselves in the 'mouth of the cannon', receiving accusations of treason and collaboration and the label 'Zionists'." He said: "May God grant you well-being, for your toil has not gone in vain. From now until the implementation of 1559 is completed and we are finished with a handful of criminals, my struggle and all my effort will be focused on founding the free 'Christian Republic of Mount Lebanon'. Long live you, and long live Lebanon."

In conclusion, Mourad thanked all the "federalist comrades" for their long struggle and for every effort they made, placing themselves in the "mouth of the cannon", receiving accusations of treason and collaboration and the label "Zionists", and said: "May God grant you well-being, for your toil has not gone in vain. From now until the implementation of 1559 is completed and we are finished with a handful of criminals, my struggle and all my effort will be focused on founding the free 'Christian Republic of Mount Lebanon'. Long live you, and long live Lebanon."

Amin Iskandar:

For his part, Dr. Amin Iskandar, President of the Maronite Union-Tur Levnon, delivered a speech titled: "Transnational Identities Do Not Allow for Federalism."

Iskandar stated that in Switzerland federalism is possible because religion takes precedence.

German-speaking Catholic Swiss voted to be part of the French-speaking Catholic canton, and not part of the German-speaking Protestant canton. So the identity is religious and not transnational, since there is no desire to be annexed to France, Germany or Italy.

On the other hand, in Kosovo, the desire to join Albania, through transnational Islam, led to partition and not federalism.

French-speaking Belgians do not dream of being annexed to France.

So Belgian federalism, being based on religious differences, is possible.

In Lebanon, however, the dispute is over identity and belonging.

As long as Lebanese Sunnis cannot consider themselves outside Arabism, and as long as Lebanese Shiites put sect before nationality, federalism is not possible.

Federalism will only be possible after partition.

In one part of Lebanon, federalization between the Druze and the Christians is possible.

Administrative decentralization may also be sufficient between them, because the Druze and the Christians recognize borders, national identities, and the separation between the secular and the religious. Not to mention their shared approaches to the relationship with:

the Creator, with the other human being without class distinctions, and with land defined by borders.

And if East Timor was able to gain independence from 270 million Indonesians, Mount Lebanon can achieve that to sustain its people.

Laws, constitutions, borders and states were created to serve human beings, not human beings sacrificed for the sanctification of borders and constitutions.

Several peoples were subjected to genocide in the last hundred years of human history. Among them were those who made this genocide a cause for protecting their existence, and among them were those who failed to create political momentum for their cause, so their existence remained threatened with no horizon. I will choose the Jews, the Armenians, the Christians of East Timor, the Muslim Bosnian people in the former Yugoslavia, the Muslim Rohingya people in Myanmar, the Kurdish people in Iraq, and the Christians of Lebanon.

Nadim Bustani:

For his part, founding member of the Permanent Conference for Federalism, lawyer Nadim Youssef Bustani, said that we must warn of the danger of the discourse calling for the abolition of "political sectarianism", since in the Lebanese situation it is not a reformist demand so much as one of the acts that pave the way for the crime of genocide. Citizenship is thereby transformed from a value that imposes equality into a tool for the dominance of the factional majority, giving it a license to practice tyranny against the minority. In this way, threatened sects are removed from the circle of groups protected under international law, and aggression against them is then turned into an internal affair or one of the forms of political conflict. And since, in our day, the circumstances that necessitated the emergence of the entity more than a hundred years ago have changed, the Lebanese system has become incapable of providing protection from the danger of genocide for the sects that feel threatened. It has therefore become a duty to shift to the formula that protects pluralism from the danger of totalitarianism and persecution, for what matters is protecting human dignity, not protecting the system. Let it be federalism today, otherwise let it be partition.

In conclusion, there were interventions from the attendees. Riachi said that the conference's recommendations would be distributed soon, adding that we have today moved to a new phase that may pave the way for the birth of a "New Lebanon".

Share

More like this